AutoGear
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Formula 1
      • STANDINGS
    • Formula E
    • Circuits
    • WRC
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語
No Result
View All Result
AutoGear
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Formula 1
      • STANDINGS
    • Formula E
    • Circuits
    • WRC
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語
No Result
View All Result
AutoGear

NASCAR Fights Back: Files Motion to Dismiss 23XI and Front Row’s Antitrust Lawsuit

Carl Harrison by Carl Harrison
December 3, 2024
in Motorsports
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
NASCAR Fights Back: Files Motion to Dismiss 23XI and Front Row’s Antitrust Lawsuit

Jun 10, 2023; Sonoma, California, USA; 23XI team logo is on display in front of the trailer before the start of the Xfinity Series DoorDash 250 at Sonoma Raceway. Mandatory Credit: Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports

NASCAR has struck back against the antitrust lawsuit filed by 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports, calling the claims “misguided” and based on contractual frustrations rather than genuine antitrust issues. On Monday, the racing organization formally requested a dismissal of the case, marking a pivotal moment in the legal battle that could reshape the sport’s governance.


NASCAR’s Defense: Four Pillars of Dismissal

In its motion, NASCAR outlined four key arguments for dismissing the lawsuit:

1. Time-Barred Claims

NASCAR argued that most allegations are outside the four-year statute of limitations. These include disputes over:

  • NASCAR’s acquisition of the ARCA Menards Series (2018) and International Speedway Corporation (2019),
  • Requirements for the Next Gen car introduced in 2020,
  • NASCAR’s exclusive agreements with racetracks, and
  • The original charter agreement.

According to NASCAR, these older grievances cannot legally form the basis of the lawsuit.

2. Lack of Antitrust Standing

The motion claims that because 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports did not sign the 2025 charter agreement, they are not bound by its contested provisions, including the release and non-compete clauses. NASCAR argues that without signing, these teams face no “concrete injury” and remain free to race elsewhere or even start their own league.

“Failure to secure preferred contractual terms is not an antitrust injury,” NASCAR stated.

3. Flawed Market Definition

NASCAR asserted that the lawsuit improperly defines the market, focusing on post-investment conditions instead of pre-investment dynamics. This, according to the motion, undermines the legal basis of the plaintiffs’ claims.

4. No Exclusionary Conduct

Finally, NASCAR emphasized that it did not refuse to engage with the teams. Instead, it offered contractual terms that the plaintiffs rejected. NASCAR also pointed out that the contested charter provisions, such as non-compete clauses, do not demonstrably harm market competition.


Jim France Speaks Out

NASCAR chairman and CEO Jim France filed a memorandum supporting the dismissal. France dismissed claims that he orchestrated a scheme to stifle competition, asserting that the allegations lacked factual substance.

“The claims fail to plausibly allege any scheme designed to achieve anticompetitive ends,” France stated.


The Lawsuit: A Recap

23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports filed their lawsuit in October, accusing NASCAR and the France family of monopolistic practices. The teams claim these practices stifle competition and prevent fair negotiations. A motion for a preliminary injunction to race as charter teams in 2025 was denied in November, forcing the teams to refile in district court.

While the plaintiffs aim to challenge NASCAR’s dominance, the league argues that the lawsuit stems from the teams’ dissatisfaction with rejected contract negotiations.


What’s Next?

The two teams have until December 16 to respond to NASCAR’s dismissal motion. This timeline ensures the legal battle will carry into the off-season, potentially shaping the landscape of NASCAR governance and team operations.

As the lawsuit progresses, it raises critical questions about competition, fairness, and the balance of power within NASCAR. The outcome could set a precedent for how disputes between governing bodies and teams are resolved in professional sports. Will 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports prevail, or will NASCAR maintain its grip on the racing world? Stay tuned.

Share233Tweet146Send

Related Posts

Racer’s Paradise: Austin Dillon’s Passion Ignites for Homestead’s Championship Showdown
Motorsports

Racer’s Paradise: Austin Dillon’s Passion Ignites for Homestead’s Championship Showdown

In a shocking revelation, NASCAR star Austin Dillon has voiced his excitement for the upcoming 2026 Championship decider race at...

by Publisher
May 13, 2025
Oscar Piastri’s Secret Weapon Unleashed: How He Crushes F1 Title Rivals with Stealth
Motorsports

Oscar Piastri’s Secret Weapon Unleashed: How He Crushes F1 Title Rivals with Stealth

Rising Star Oscar Piastri Outshines F1 Competitors with Unorthodox Tactics In a thrilling turn of events in the F1 world,...

by Harry Stone
May 13, 2025
Mick Schumacher Urged by Former F1 Champion to Strategize Comeback with Influential Figures
Motorsports

Sebastian Vettel Champions Mick Schumacher for Cadillac F1 Comeback: Explosive Revelation!

Sebastian Vettel Endorses Mick Schumacher for Cadillac with Bold Prediction A potential game-changer is looming in the world of Formula...

by Harry Stone
May 13, 2025
F1 Bombshell: Ex-Ferrari Engineer Prefers Verstappen Over Russell at Mercedes
Motorsports

F1 Bombshell: Ex-Ferrari Engineer Prefers Verstappen Over Russell at Mercedes

Former Ferrari engineer drops bombshell: Would swap Russell for Verstappen! In a shocking revelation, Rob Smedley, a former Ferrari engineer...

by David Castro
May 13, 2025

Recent News

Racer’s Paradise: Austin Dillon’s Passion Ignites for Homestead’s Championship Showdown

Racer’s Paradise: Austin Dillon’s Passion Ignites for Homestead’s Championship Showdown

May 13, 2025
Oscar Piastri’s Secret Weapon Unleashed: How He Crushes F1 Title Rivals with Stealth

Oscar Piastri’s Secret Weapon Unleashed: How He Crushes F1 Title Rivals with Stealth

May 13, 2025
Mick Schumacher Urged by Former F1 Champion to Strategize Comeback with Influential Figures

Sebastian Vettel Champions Mick Schumacher for Cadillac F1 Comeback: Explosive Revelation!

May 13, 2025
F1 Bombshell: Ex-Ferrari Engineer Prefers Verstappen Over Russell at Mercedes

F1 Bombshell: Ex-Ferrari Engineer Prefers Verstappen Over Russell at Mercedes

May 13, 2025

Newsletter

  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TECHNICAL INFORMATION
  • EDITORIAL STATUS
  • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

© 2023 AutoGear - Todos os direitos reservados AutoGear.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Formula 1
      • STANDINGS
    • Formula E
    • Circuits
    • WRC
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語

© 2023 AutoGear - Todos os direitos reservados AutoGear.

Enable Notifications OK No thanks
x