AutoGear
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Circuits
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語
  • STANDINGS
No Result
View All Result
AutoGear
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Circuits
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語
  • STANDINGS
No Result
View All Result
AutoGear

McLaren and F1 Stewards Clash Over Controversial Penalty for Norris in US GP

Harry Bright by Harry Bright
January 9, 2025
in Motorsports
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
McLaren and F1 Stewards Clash Over Controversial Penalty for Norris in US GP

Oct 20, 2024; Austin, Texas, USA; McLaren Formula 1 Team driver Lando Norris (4) of Team Great Britain drives during the 2024 Formula One US Grand Prix at Circuit of the Americas. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

 The 2024 United States Grand Prix sparked fresh controversy as McLaren’s Lando Norris was handed a five-second penalty for an overtake on Max Verstappen, a decision that McLaren team principal Andrea Stella slammed as “inappropriate interference” in what he called “a beautiful piece of motorsport.”

The penalty, which cost Norris a podium finish, has reignited debate over Formula 1’s racing rules, as well as the consistency and fairness of stewarding decisions. In the closing stages of the race at Circuit of the Americas, Norris, on fresher tyres, made an ambitious move around the outside of Verstappen at Turn 12. Both drivers went off track, but the stewards ruled that Norris gained an advantage by doing so, issuing the penalty that dropped him from third to fourth place.

McLaren was furious, with Stella expressing disbelief that the stewards intervened in what he felt was hard, fair racing between two of the sport’s top drivers. “My view is that the way the stewards interfered with a beautiful piece of motorsport was inappropriate because both cars went off track,” Stella told Sky Sports F1. “Both cars gained an advantage. It’s a shame because it cost us a podium.”

The decision left McLaren questioning why they should have instructed Norris to hand back the position when, in their view, the move was legitimate. “There was no doubt the move was correct,” Stella added, emphasizing that the chapter was closed due to the inability to appeal the stewards’ ruling.

Norris himself was equally unimpressed. The Briton, who had fought hard throughout the race after losing positions at the start, pointed out the inconsistency in the rules. “He [Verstappen] defends by going off track, he overtakes by going off track, but I’m not going to complain about it,” Norris remarked, while still praising Verstappen’s driving. “Max drove well, he defended well, we had a good race together, but the rules are the rules.”

Red Bull, however, defended the decision, with team principal Christian Horner and Verstappen both standing by the ruling. “It’s quite clear you can’t overtake outside the white line,” Verstappen said, while Horner referenced Verstappen’s own 2017 penalty at the same track when he was penalized for passing Kimi Raikkonen off track, drawing a parallel to this incident.

The controversy deepened when considering an earlier flashpoint between the two title contenders at Turn 1 on Lap 1. Verstappen aggressively dove down the inside, forcing Norris wide and dropping him from pole position to fourth. Despite McLaren’s protests, this incident wasn’t investigated, with the stewards apparently considering it part of the chaotic first-lap racing that often sees more lenient interpretations of the rules.

The core issue, many argue, lies in F1’s over-complicated racing guidelines. The current rules dictate that if a driver overtakes on the outside, they must be level with their rival’s front axle by the apex of the corner to claim space. Verstappen, likely aware of this, appeared to force Norris into a position where he couldn’t claim the corner, leading to the off-track overtake and subsequent penalty.

“Verstappen knew exactly what he was doing,” one commentator said. “He forced Norris into a situation where he had no choice but to back off or go off track. When Norris didn’t back off, the penalty was inevitable.”

While the penalty decision followed the letter of the law, many—including McLaren—argue that the guidelines themselves are the problem. They allow drivers to manipulate situations, pushing opponents off track while staying within the rules. This creates what Stella called an artificial restriction on racing: “This is what happens when the art of racing is reduced to driving to guidelines.”

The Norris-Verstappen incident is just the latest in a growing list of controversies surrounding how F1 governs racing on track. As teams push for consistency, the sport risks tying itself into regulatory knots, leaving drivers, teams, and fans frustrated with decisions that seem to undermine the spirit of competition.

In this case, McLaren might rue not telling Norris to hand the position back immediately, as Horner suggested they should have. With five laps remaining, Norris had the pace to try again—but the gamble cost him. As the dust settles, it’s clear that F1’s quest for “consistency” has once again sparked inconsistency in how races are decided, leaving all sides searching for clarity.

 

Share212Tweet133Send

Related Posts

Zandvoort Faces Catastrophic Thunderstorm: Dutch GP Weekend in Jeopardy!
Motorsports

Zandvoort Faces Catastrophic Thunderstorm: Dutch GP Weekend in Jeopardy!

Thunderstorm Wreaks Havoc at Zandvoort: Dutch GP in Jeopardy! As the Dutch Grand Prix weekend approaches, ominous clouds have gathered...

by James Taylor
August 28, 2025
Alonso Rallies Behind Hamilton: “He Doesn’t Need to Prove Anything!” Amidst Ferrari Struggles
Motorsports

Alonso Rallies Behind Hamilton: “He Doesn’t Need to Prove Anything!” Amidst Ferrari Struggles

Formula One F1 - Hungarian Grand Prix - Hungaroring, Budapest, Hungary - August 2, 2025 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso after...

by Harry Bright
August 28, 2025
George Russell Faces ‘High-Stakes’ Contract Gamble as Mercedes Deal Looms for 2026
Motorsports

George Russell Faces ‘High-Stakes’ Contract Gamble as Mercedes Deal Looms for 2026

Formula One F1 - Belgian Grand Prix - Circuit de Spa-Francorchamps, Stavelot, Belgium - July 24, 2025 Mercedes' George Russell...

by Harry Bright
August 28, 2025
Lando Norris’ 2025 Regrets: The Heroic Mistakes That Cost Him the Championship
Motorsports

Lando Norris’ 2025 Regrets: The Heroic Mistakes That Cost Him the Championship

Formula One F1 - Hungarian Grand Prix - Hungaroring, Budapest, Hungary - July 31, 2025 McLaren's Lando Norris arrives ahead...

by Arthur Ling
August 28, 2025

Recent News

Zandvoort Faces Catastrophic Thunderstorm: Dutch GP Weekend in Jeopardy!

Zandvoort Faces Catastrophic Thunderstorm: Dutch GP Weekend in Jeopardy!

August 28, 2025
Alonso Rallies Behind Hamilton: “He Doesn’t Need to Prove Anything!” Amidst Ferrari Struggles

Alonso Rallies Behind Hamilton: “He Doesn’t Need to Prove Anything!” Amidst Ferrari Struggles

August 28, 2025
George Russell Faces ‘High-Stakes’ Contract Gamble as Mercedes Deal Looms for 2026

George Russell Faces ‘High-Stakes’ Contract Gamble as Mercedes Deal Looms for 2026

August 28, 2025
Lando Norris’ 2025 Regrets: The Heroic Mistakes That Cost Him the Championship

Lando Norris’ 2025 Regrets: The Heroic Mistakes That Cost Him the Championship

August 28, 2025

Newsletter

  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TECHNICAL INFORMATION
  • EDITORIAL STATUS
  • TERMS AND CONDITIONS

© 2023 AutoGear - Todos os direitos reservados AutoGear.

No Result
View All Result
  • Latest News
  • AutoGear TV
  • Sustainable Mobility
  • Motorsports
    • Circuits
    • Rally
    • Rally raid
    • WEC
  • English
    • Português
    • Italiano
    • Français
    • Español
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • 日本語

© 2023 AutoGear - Todos os direitos reservados AutoGear.

Enable Notifications OK No thanks