The FIA’s use of former F1 drivers as race stewards has ignited a fresh wave of criticism, especially after recent penalties imposed on Max Verstappen. Jos Verstappen, father of the three-time world champion, launched a sharp critique of the FIA, highlighting what he sees as biased and inconsistent stewarding that unfairly impacts the championship battle.
The controversy centers around two recent incidents in Austin and Mexico, where Max Verstappen faced penalties in his heated battles with McLaren’s Lando Norris. In Austin, fans and analysts alike questioned the decision not to penalize Verstappen for pushing Norris off-track, while Norris himself was penalized for an overtake outside track limits. Then, in Mexico, Verstappen was hit with two 10-second penalties for off-track infractions, which Jos Verstappen felt were exaggerated.
One of the main targets of Jos’s frustration is former F1 driver and steward Johnny Herbert, who he claims showed favoritism toward Norris. “It’s about clarity, consistency, and objectivity,” Jos emphasized, suggesting that former drivers may bring personal biases to their stewarding roles. He believes that former drivers, especially those with nationality ties, can’t always remain impartial, and he wants to see the FIA adopt a more professional and objective approach.
“If you have the same people every time, you’re going to get the same decisions. That’s just better,” Jos stated, calling for FIA-appointed stewards who understand racing but remain distanced from any personal interests. He argued that Formula 1 needs a similar professional system to soccer, where FIFA referees receive training and oversight.
Johnny Herbert responded to the backlash, asserting his right to express his own views outside his official role. “Everyone has an opinion,” Herbert said. “Why can’t I when I am not at the racetrack? The racetrack has been my world for 50 years. If I don’t quite agree with what I see on the racetrack, I will say so. It is not just Max. I’ll criticize anyone if I feel it is warranted.”
For Max Verstappen, however, the criticism seemed to fuel his determination. After clinching an impressive victory in Brazil from 17th on the grid, Verstappen sent a clear message to his critics, showing that his on-track performance speaks louder than any debate over his driving style or penalties. With the championship race as intense as ever, calls for FIA reform are likely to continue, as drivers and teams demand greater clarity and impartiality in stewarding decisions.
