In a shocking turn of events, Alpine F1’s decision to replace Jack Doohan with Franco Colapinto has sparked controversy within the Formula 1 community. The move, which saw Doohan being benched just a quarter of the way into the 2025 season, has raised questions about the treatment of rookies in the sport.
Oliver Bearman, a fellow rookie from the Haas F1 Team, did not hold back in criticizing Alpine’s handling of the situation, labeling it as “incredibly harsh.” Bearman expressed empathy for Doohan’s plight, highlighting the immense pressure rookies face in their debut season, especially with the challenges posed by the current generation of F1 cars.
The decision to replace Doohan has divided opinions among drivers, with some arguing that talent alone should guarantee success in F1. However, others, like Bearman, point out the complexities and nuances involved in modern Formula 1, where factors such as team support, car performance, and external pressures play significant roles in a driver’s success.
Fernando Alonso, a two-time F1 champion, offered a contrasting view, suggesting that rookies today are well-prepared through extensive training and developmental programs. However, the rapid turnover of drivers, as seen in Doohan’s case, raises concerns about the nurturing of young talent in the sport.
The role of team managers and advisors, such as Flavio Briatore, in shaping the careers of young drivers has also come under scrutiny in light of Doohan’s replacement. Briatore’s influence in the decision-making process has added another layer of intrigue to the unfolding drama in the F1 paddock.
As the debate rages on, the treatment of rookies in Formula 1 remains a contentious issue, with Doohan’s case serving as a stark reminder of the unforgiving nature of top-tier motorsport. Stay tuned for more updates on this developing story as the F1 season progresses.