As Lewis Hamilton prepares to don Ferrari red for the 2025 Formula 1 season, motorsport pundits are drawing parallels between his move and Michael Schumacher’s less-than-stellar post-retirement stint with Mercedes. Former F1 driver David Coulthard has cautioned that Hamilton, despite his unparalleled success, could face an uphill battle as he transitions to Ferrari, where he’ll compete alongside the electric Charles Leclerc.
A Career Defining Gamble
Hamilton’s departure from Mercedes, the team that delivered him six of his seven world championships, is as bold as it is surprising. At 39 years old, the British superstar now faces what Coulthard calls “a roll of the dice” with Ferrari, a team he once rivaled fiercely. Coulthard warned that while Hamilton’s ambition to chase his record-breaking eighth championship is admirable, the challenges of adapting to a new team and facing a younger, equally hungry teammate in Leclerc cannot be underestimated.
Schumacher’s Mercedes Return: A Sobering Parallel
Coulthard drew comparisons to Schumacher, who returned to F1 in 2010 with Mercedes after retiring as a Ferrari legend in 2006. Despite high expectations, the German icon’s comeback fell short, yielding just one podium in three seasons. While Hamilton’s scenario differs in that he remains an active competitor rather than a retiree making a return, Coulthard pointed out the similarities:
“When Michael came back from retirement to sign for Mercedes, it was really shocking to imagine him being anything other than a Ferrari legend. He did okay, but it wasn’t the same as in his first stint in Formula 1.”
The Leclerc Challenge
Ferrari’s Charles Leclerc, fresh off a 2024 season where he narrowly missed the Drivers’ Championship, presents a formidable obstacle for Hamilton. Coulthard emphasized that Leclerc’s speed and familiarity with the Ferrari team could make life difficult for the Briton:
“Lewis is rolling the dice again with Ferrari. It may well lead to a rejuvenation of performance and a fight for the world championship. But it is going to be challenging because he has got to beat a very fast Charles Leclerc.”
The dynamic between the two Ferrari drivers will undoubtedly be a focal point in 2025. Hamilton’s ability to deliver consistent qualifying and race performances, especially against a teammate of Leclerc’s caliber, will determine whether his move is a masterstroke or a misstep.
A Test of Longevity and Greatness
Coulthard also touched on the unique challenge posed by Hamilton’s age, noting that while his racecraft remains exceptional, the rigors of Formula 1 require consistent peak performance across a season. He framed Hamilton’s move as an opportunity to prove whether he still has the edge:
“If Lewis, at 40 years old, has lost a yard in footballing terms, then he may well struggle to beat Charles over the course of a year.
“That is a legitimate question, but it is for him to show us. It’s not about us putting him down; it’s about him shaping his own future.”
Ferrari’s Gamble on a Legend
For Ferrari, Hamilton represents both a sporting and symbolic investment. The Scuderia is counting on the seven-time champion to bring experience and a championship-winning mentality to a team that last tasted a title in 2008. The stakes are high for both parties, and the results of this partnership could redefine Hamilton’s legacy—or challenge his dominance in the twilight of his career.