The 2025 Formula 1 season is already buzzing with one burning question: should Sergio Pérez stay at Red Bull, or is it time for fresh blood to take the wheel? As the Mexican driver faces growing scrutiny, Red Bull finds itself at a pivotal moment that could define its future success.
The Struggles of 2024: A Season to Forget
Sergio Pérez entered the 2024 season with high hopes but left with more questions than answers. While his teammate Max Verstappen claimed nine wins and remained in a league of his own, Pérez’s performances were riddled with inconsistency. He faced persistent braking issues in low-speed corners, struggled to adapt to Red Bull’s demanding car, and saw his confidence erode.
The team’s early decision to extend Pérez’s contract now feels like a gamble that didn’t pay off. Instead of providing stability, it has forced Red Bull to confront the consequences of a second driver unable to keep pace with Verstappen.
Despite this, Pérez wasn’t without his moments. He’s a proven race winner, a driver capable of holding his nerve under pressure, and a reliable points scorer when the car suits him. But in the high-stakes world of Formula 1, “good enough” doesn’t cut it—especially not at Red Bull, a team known for its relentless pursuit of perfection.
The Case for Keeping Pérez
For all his struggles, Pérez brings a wealth of experience that few drivers can match. He’s been on the grid for over a decade, understands racecraft, and has the temperament to perform under challenging conditions. His ability to deliver consistent points is invaluable in a sport where every point counts toward the Constructors’ Championship.
If Red Bull can fine-tune the 2025 car to address the braking issues that plagued Pérez in 2024, there’s a chance he could rediscover his form. A driver with his experience might be precisely what Red Bull needs to stabilize their campaign after losing the Constructors’ title to McLaren last year.
The Argument for Change
However, the counterargument is compelling. Red Bull’s dominance relies on having two cars fighting at the front, and Pérez hasn’t been able to deliver that. While Verstappen excels, Pérez’s frequent Q1 and Q2 exits and lack of podium finishes since the Chinese Grand Prix have raised serious concerns. Outqualified by midfield drivers on several occasions, Pérez has often been more of a liability than an asset.
Red Bull’s priority is clear: they need a second driver who can push Verstappen harder or at least stay closer to him. The current gap between the two drivers is simply too wide for a team with championship ambitions.
The Candidates to Replace Pérez
If Red Bull opts for change, they won’t be short on options. Two names stand out:
- Yuki Tsunoda
Tsunoda has shown significant growth during his time with Red Bull’s sister team. Steady performances, combined with recent testing experience for the senior team, make him a strong contender. He’s familiar with Red Bull’s operations and has the potential to step up. - Liam Lawson
Lawson impressed during his substitute appearances for Daniel Ricciardo in 2023 and secured a full-time seat at Red Bull’s sister team in 2024. His raw speed and composure under pressure have made him a rising star and a legitimate candidate for the top seat.
And then there’s Daniel Ricciardo, the fan favorite who knows Red Bull inside out. While Ricciardo’s results have been inconsistent, his experience and charisma make him a wildcard option if the team wants a seasoned campaigner.
The Risks of Change
Switching drivers always carries risks. Tsunoda and Lawson may show promise, but stepping into a Red Bull seat comes with immense pressure. If either struggles to adapt or falters under the weight of expectation, Red Bull could find themselves worse off. Even Ricciardo, with all his experience, would face an uphill battle to regain his best form.
Red Bull must weigh these risks against the potential rewards. Stability has its merits, but in a sport as competitive as Formula 1, taking calculated risks is often the path to success.
What’s at Stake?
Beyond performance, Red Bull’s decision sends a message to the paddock. Keeping Pérez would signal a commitment to stability and experience, while replacing him could underline the team’s ruthless pursuit of excellence. It would also demonstrate faith in their talent pipeline, showcasing confidence in the likes of Tsunoda or Lawson.
But if the gamble doesn’t pay off, Red Bull risks destabilizing their lineup and potentially falling further behind McLaren in the Constructors’ battle.
The Final Verdict
At this point, the writing seems to be on the wall for Sergio Pérez. While his experience and occasional brilliance make a strong case for keeping him, his inability to consistently deliver at Red Bull’s level has left the team with little choice but to consider alternatives.
Whether it’s Tsunoda, Lawson, or even Ricciardo, Red Bull’s next move will define their trajectory for years to come. Stability or a bold gamble? Only time will tell. One thing is certain: Red Bull cannot afford to get it wrong.